Wednesday, April 24, 2019

Framing Our Reading, Part 3







This week, Susan, Courtney, and I stuck with Statistics in finding an article on the Oakland A’s and Moneyball. This article talks about how Billy Beane used sabermetrics to change the way data analytics and statistics were used in the MLB. The article breaks down an example of a 1-Proportion Test and proves that Billy Beane’s statistical analysis was actually very accurate. This article also hits the three components of text complexity, qualitative, quantitative, and the reader and the task (Burke). The qualitative aspect of the article is that is furthers the students understanding of the topic of statistical testing and analysis. The quantitative aspect is that the text is appropriate and at the reading level of high school AP seniors. The reader and the task aspect is that the students will have prior knowledge to this information because the article is an extension to the lesson to show how these tests are used in the real world.

As the reader, this article packs in lot of information. It gives important definitions for different components that are calculated in a 1-Proportion Test and what each element means in terms of the problem. One of the important things that I found in this article was the meaning behind the p-value. Another important thing that I found in this article were the images of the tests because it gives each piece that is used to calculate the statistics. I also found that the article highlighting the percentage of the Oakland A’s winning 20 consecutive games and how it was calculated is important, as well. The quote that stuck out to me was when the article was referenced the trade of Pena and Giambi,

Pena and Giambi were traded at the end of May, when the A’s record was 20-26. Oakland went 83-33 the rest of the season. By the looks of it, these trades helped!

This was a shock when I was reading because it was just proof that the numbers don’t lie, and Billy Beane was on to something with his statistical analysis. Some of the key words in this article are p-value, significant, binomial distribution, and 1-Proportion Test. These words are key vocabulary words in the probability unit that are needed to be familiar with in order to grasp the data that is being explained in the article and how the numbers came about to form conclusions.

There are many important pieces to this article I found as I read. I was able to relate to the article because it was from a relevant movie of a sport that I know, baseball. It also gave an example of how statistics is used in the real world and how it is such an important aspect of the sports. The calculator images of the components of a 1-Proportion Test and a binomial distribution lend to where each piece of the calculation comes from and how to interpret their meanings. Importantly, this article explains how to find probability for consecutive wins, so the reader can get a better image of the importance of statistics and how it helped the A’s turn out a better record than before and save millions. The message this reading gave to me was that statistics is an asset to not just the game of baseball, but to many other sports and aspects of real life.

As the teacher, I found that this sports article is packed with good information that statistics students will see throughout the year. The key concepts of how 1-Proportion Tests can be used outside of the classroom and how it has benefitted a larger organization are important in showing students possible future career paths they could take that use what we are actually learning in class. The images and break down of the tests and how to interpret the results are most important in this article. In order for students to grasp those concepts, they need to know some background on the process if running a 1-Proportion Test and a binomial distribution. This will enable students in understanding the meaning of the article. The perspective of this article is straight forward, informational, and potentially pro Oakland. The author does a good job of adding in a little humor to the article with some side comments, such as “… to find the answer I could multiple .636 by itself 20 times….ooooooooor I could be lazy and have Minitab do it. I’m going to go with lazy”. This may seem to give mixed messages to students, but a lot of statistical analysis is done on some type of calculator that is programmed to spit out an answer given the right information, so I took this as students can see that there are resources out there that can make their lives easier. The author’s purpose of this was to demonstrate that there are applications where this type of test can be used and how it is important, so when a student asks, “when am I ever going to use this?”, you can respond “when you become a baseball statistical analyst.” In addition to this article having a good mix of unit vocabulary and being about a relatable subject matter, it is short, so student engagement and attention should not be lost. I also found that this article went well with a few standards that I covered in Statistics this year. Some of the standards this article covers are,

·       ~ S.IC.1 – Understand statistics as a process for making inferences about population parameters based on a random sample from that population
·       ~ S.IC.6 – Evaluate reports based on data
·       ~ S.CP.2 – Understand that two events A and B are independent if the probability of A and B occurring together is the product of their probabilities and use this characterization to determine if they are independent
·        ~ S.IC.4 – Use data from a sample survey to estimate a population mean or proportion

These standards are found in almost every unit of a Statistics course, which make this article a good fit for my classes.

In determining a strategy to use for this article, my group chose paired summarizing. “Paired summarizing provides a format for two students to work together to express their understandings and summarize narrative or informational text” (McLaughlin, 2015). I will begin this by explaining to students how to summarize and identify essential information. Then I would demonstrate by showing the students a short paragraph and model identifying key information, so they know what types of things to look for in this article. Once students know what is expected and what to do, then I allow students to work with a partner and guide them into paired questioning. They will read the article independently and summarize on their own, then they will compare and contrast their summaries with one another. As the teacher, I will be encouraging them to ask questions on what one another has summarized and what information they thought to be important. At the end, we would come together as a class to come up with one class summary.  This strategy would be effective for my students because it allows them to compare viewpoints on what others think is important in reading. It also helps them to learn how to identify key information apart from information that may be filler or unnecessary in identifying the message.



References

Burke, B. A Close Look at Close Reading.

McLaughlin, M. (2015). Content Area Reading: Teaching and Learning for College and Career Readiness. Pearson Education

Thursday, April 18, 2019

Framing Out Reading, Part 2


This week, Courtney, Susan, and I chose an article on the Patriots titled No, CBS Sports, the Patriots Have not Found an Edge on Coin Flips by Harrison Chase. We picked this article because it gives a real-world example of finding the probability of multiple independent events occurring. It has a good mix of vocabulary from the probability unit and has some rare words as well. The article came from a sports blog called Harvard Sports Analysis, which we found by doing a Google search.

As the reader, I found this text to aid in the understanding of how to find the probability of multiple independent events. The most significant parts of this text were the breakdown of the probability of the Patriots winning 19 of 25 coin tosses, the probability that at least one team in the NFL can achieve this, and the probability of this not happening at all. The quotation that stuck out to me the most was,
Even if you restricted it to not all results as extreme in either direction but just results of 19 or greater, the probability of one or more teams achieving that is still nearly 20%.
This quote stuck with me as I read the article because as I thought about the probability of continuously winning a coin flip over 50% of the time, I thought that that percentage was somewhat higher than expected. Some of the words that are important were probability, independent, simulation, and significant. These words are important to know the definition and their meaning in statistics to understand the breakdown of the data being presented in the article.

In teaching the students using this text, students need to know vocabulary and process of finding the probability of multiple independent events. If events are independent, they need to know to multiple each probability of each separate success of an event together. In this case, they need to know the probability of a coin toss. The background that they would be given for this would be an exploration in simulating a coin toss. When I introduce this concept to students, we do labs with coin toss and dice roll to see that none of the events depend on the outcome of one another and they are they are separate and independent. The meaning behind this article is not a complex one. It takes students through finding the probability of winning and losing multiple coin tosses for one team and across multiple teams. The author shares some of his biases in supporting the Patriots with statements such as, “clearly with Deflategate out of the way the media is looking for something else to accuse the Patriots of” and “both common sense and statistics will tell you that the Patriots have not been cheating by winning coin flips at an ‘impossible’ rate”. Though it is from his point of view, it does not change the mathematics presented. The article also flows well with going through the probability of the Patriots winning 19 out of 25 coin flips, winning fewer than 6 coin flips, at least one team having a record of 19 out of 25 flip wins out of 32 teams, and the probability of one or more teams achieving that coin flip record. The author also makes these comparisons to prove his point that the Patriots are not cheating during coin flips. This sports article is used to support the Patriots against media criticism for cheating at another aspect of football and gives a breakdown of the math to support the case.

The strategy I am using for this article is paired questioning. “In Paired Questioning, students engage in actively generating questions during reading” (McLaughlin, 2015). I would integrate this strategy into my lesson using this article by doing 5 steps, explain, demonstrate, guide, practice, and reflect. I would explain paired questioning to them and how the activity is going to flow with the student and their pair generating questions to one another, taking turns asking and answering. I would demonstrate this explanation with them using an example from a previous reading we had done in class. Because the article is not separated into sections, I would have the students look at the first three paragraphs, then the paragraph 4, then paragraphs 5 and 6. Once the students have read the three sections, engaging in paired questioning at the end of each one, I would have them look at the article as a whole and have them state their opinions and knowledge from what they were able to grasp from the article. At the end, the class would reflect on our opinions and understandings of the text.

I think that this article, though short, is a good break down on how probability is used to analyze sports. It incorporates vocabulary from the unit and calculations learned. It has a good mix of vocabulary and biases from the author, who seems to be in support of the Patriots. Each student can form their opinion on whether they think the Patriots are “cheaters” based on their understanding of the article and their view on the Patriots outside of the article. I think this article can strike controversy amongst classmates based on who their favorite NFL team.

References
McLaughlin, M. (2015). Content Area Reading: Teaching and Learning for College and Career Readiness. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson.

Chase, H. (2015, November 5). No, CBS Sports, the Patriots have not found an edge on coin flips. Retrieved from http://harvardsportsanalysis.org/2015/11/nocbs/?fbclid=IwAR1PyAfLz1qT0efdRRWW5W7AQz6lvR-bB6GurcBNWDVMYcycfEO6WCcGqe0

Friday, April 12, 2019

Framing Our Reading, Part 1



Article Title: Wait, Have We Really Wiped Out 60 Percent of Animals?


A tiger

For this week’s article, Courtney and I chose to go with an article about animal extinction statistics. We chose this article because it gives examples of false data leading to inaccurate conclusions and bias. We found this text by picking article topics that we think our students would find interesting, such as animals and extinction. The article also did not have an overwhelming amount of complex or rare words and had vocabulary that is found in the unit of introducing statistics and probability. The article comes from a reputable source called The Atlantic, which has a variety of interesting engaging articles.

When reading this article, I found many key elements that were significant to the lesson and to understanding the author’s message. Some things that I found to be most significant for the lesson was bias between animals that are studied more than others, how statistics of a small sample can skew the big picture, and how statistics can be misleading. Bias, the hinderance of smaller sample sizes, and misleading statistics were shown through examples of how animals that are studied more have more data and animals that are studies less have less data, so to get their true population numbers for those species that there is not as much known is more difficult. So, to say that in the past 40 years, 60% of animals have been wiped out is not totally accurate. With this, a quote that stuck out to me was,

Since prehistory, humans have killed off so many species of mammals that it would take 3 million to 7 million years of evolution for them to evolve an equivalent amount of diversity.
This alarming statement made me think about mammals, such as the sabretooth tiger and the woolly mammoth. These animals were said to have been driven to by hunters and global warming, but there is only so much to support these theories that no one is 100% certain how they disappeared. Having variability with humans destroying animal habitats, hunting, and polluting the environment may have played a role in diminishing populations, but climate changes and other environmental elements have played a role too, which is not highlighted as heavily as human intervention. In addition, words and phrases, such as “estimated the size of different animal populations”, percent, biases, data, and “It is not a census of all wildlife but reports how wildlife populations have changed in size” all contain vocabulary and verbiage that students would see throughout a statistics course and in the first unit.

In using this text to teach students, key information in this article have to do with the variability in collecting data, sample sizes, bias, and false statistics. The background needed for this would be examples of how to spot bad data and vocabulary on words like census and biases. I believe that this text has some a few levels of meaning, such as how people can interpret statistics, how statistics does not always paint an accurate big picture, and how bias can change the meaning of statistics and messages. I feel that the overall article, however, shows one main perspective that can be possibly seen as biased based on person beliefs about the human contribution to animal extinction. This article is written in the point of view of the author and their opinion on how certain data can be misleading. You could form an opposition to the article if you are a firm supporter of human intervention causing extinction. The text does have a good, easy transition from one idea to the next and is clean in relaying information to the reader. The author refers to reports from WWF, The Guardian, and Living Planet Index. This article also has straight forward concepts and is more informational, bringing awareness to how data can be misinterpreted. The language is for a level of ability who is not familiar with how to dissect a text that contains data and how it can be misconstrued. The author is trying to convey that the statistic of saying that over the last 40 years or so that 60% of animal species have been wiped out is not totally accurate because not all variables have been accounted for in the study. This text is well organized, and I see it being a good introductory article to how statistics can be misleading.

I think that this article would be useful in making connections between real world current events and what we would be learning in class with bad data and bias. The lesson with this article would start with a recap of what bias looks like and how to determine bad data. Each student would read the article individually highlighting information that demonstrated bias and bad data and what they found interesting. After they highlighted, they would then determine the author’s message and meaning of the article. The students would then come together with a partner and participate in a think-pair-share, where they can compare the information they found to demonstrate bias and bad data, and what they took away from the article. To wrap up the class, we would come together as a class and reflect on each group’s findings and compare our opinions and thoughts on the article.

I think that this article is a good way to ease students into statistics. It allows them to see how bias and bad data can be found in real world current event. It can allow the students to form their own opinions on a text and presents an interesting topic of animal extinction. I think that with this text students can get a good understanding of bias and how data can be misconstrued.




Sunday, March 24, 2019

My Philosophy on Teaching

In reflecting on my time teaching and taking graduate course, I have acquired my own set of moral and ethics when it comes to assessing students. I think that the most important thing is to be relatable, impartial, and having students being physical and not always having a sedentary class period. Students should be assessed on their knowledge in various ways that allow them to be creative and engaged.

When trying to assess student, as the teacher, you want to be able to determine whether your students are picking up what you are teaching. Are my students retaining the information? Is there something that my students aren’t understanding? What can I do to clarify any misunderstandings and relate this to my students? These are all questions that I ask myself when I give my students a formative assessment. I think that to be a good teacher you need to be able to relate. I have had more success by having my lessons relating back to something physical the students can do or construct than pen and paper note taking and sedentary activities. I also find ways to relate to my students through their interests and career goals, for example by relating my quadratics unit to basketball and projectile motion that you would see in physics. I have also seen vast improvement on my student’s summative assessment scores at the end of the units.

Formative and performance assessments I find to be very useful in my classroom. Formative assessments allow me to track student knowledge and check for understanding. I can take this data and alter lessons or review necessary skills needed for concepts moving forward in a unit. By being impartial and fair with grading, my students are more motivated to succeed because they know that I am not just going to give them a good grade because I like them more. I do not let emotions get in the way of how I grade their work. Giving them immediate feedback, help them to also see where they are making mistakes and where they need to improve. Giving performance assessment, motivate and engage my students because they can construct something that relates to things outside of the classroom. They can demonstrate their knowledge through something that interests them and does not give the stressors that come with taking a test.

In increasing student engagement, there are many technologies that I have tried, and I would like to incorporate in the future. I have used sites such as Khan Academy, that allow my students to have video lessons, additional resources, and practice exercises with immediate feedback. I have also used applications, such as Kahoot! that I have found to be helpful when doing knowledge checks because they again give immediate feedback and allow the students to use their phones. Technologies I would like to incorporate are Nearpod and Desmos because they are able to provide more interactive lessons that a plain old PowerPoint cannot. Students can get the immediate feedback and have a digital copy of a lesson to refer to if necessary.

I think that the Experiential Learning Theory is one that I can most relate to and has helped me in my classroom. Students relate and remember things that they can experience. If a student does not see how a math skill can be used outside the classroom, they tend to not be as motivated to want to learn the material. I have created lessons that relate to projectile motion for the quadratics unit using basketball analogies and carnival games to teach probability. In my first-year teaching, I had no prior experience, so I went with teaching how I was taught when I was in high school which was mostly lectures. I noticed my students were more talkative to their neighbors and on their phones as I was trying to teach them material. When I hit about the second quarter, teaching in that manner just was not effective, so I began to try teaching with different mediums and trying to relate more to what the students were interested in. I had my students actively doing explorations and experiments that they may have seen or experienced outside the classroom, which helped to improve their engagement in my lessons.

Creating a philosophy for how I think one should teach is hard to say because there are so many factors that play into how students learn. There are those that are inside and outside the classroom as well as many different types of disabilities that play a role. With adapting to my students, being fair, unbiased, consistent and relatable have given me the most success in my current teaching environment. I do not sugar coat anything with them and I remain transparent. I find things that my students show interest in and I run with those ideas in creating effective and engaging lessons. I think that my philosophy most closely relates to Experiential Learning because many of my students learn better through the things in their lives they experience.

Sunday, March 3, 2019

Fairness with Assessment

When creating assessments, it is important to be fair. Each student should have an equally likely chance to succeed and demonstrate their knowledge and understanding of the unit content. I believe that students must be engaged and motivated in lessons, have a safe, comfortable learning environment, and be able to relate to the material. All of these things play into being to able fairly assess students.

 I believe it is the responsibility of the educator to teach the students in a way they can relate and understand the material. If the educator cannot teach in a way that it is relatable to the students, should the blame be put onto the students for not performing on their assessments? I think it is the educators responsibility to make the content relatable. A student is not going to be encouraged to learn something they cannot totally understand. Relating lessons to things that students show interest in makes the topic more memorable. For example, when teaching quadratic functions, I used a lot of basketball and football analogies to better explain the topic because there was a culture of basketball and football in the school. I also created a lab, where students were able to catapult different objects and diagram its motion.


In addition to making the lessons relatable, the learning environment must be comfortable and safe. The students must feel safe to make mistakes as they learn new material. If a student does not feel like they can make a mistake, then it will be impossible for them to learn. Students must also feel comfortable with the educator and their classmates to share answers and collaborate.


In making my own assessments as fair as possible, I need to ensure that the questions that I am asking are clear and concise. They need to be specific to what I am looking for and align with expectations. I also need to ensure that the questions match the content that was actually taught and are worded in a way that matches what the students are familiar with. The assessment needs to have multiple types of questioning and at the end of each assessment I want to add a reflection piece so I can also get feedback about the unit, so I can teach it better the following year and alter my future lessons. Bias in questioning needs to be eliminated, so that there is a leveled playing field for all.


Being an educator, I have been able to reflect on things that I did in my first year that might have not been as fair when assessing students. Though I have tried to make my assessments mirror to what was learned, I may have relied more on students knowing my expectations in giving directions. I always made my directions brief and to the point, but then when grading students may not have put all the information I am looking for to give them full points. I should have made my directions specific in order to be able to say that this or that was not done to answer the questions properly. I need to review my assessments and make sure I am giving everyone an equal chance in order to effectively assess their knowledge and my ability to teach material as well.


Saturday, February 2, 2019

Views on Standardized Testing


Standardized tests have been around for over 100 years. They have been used to check student abilities to ensure they are up to the standards of the state and country. I find that there may have been some benefits in the past, but after being on both sides of standardized testing as a student and teacher in the same county, I am starting to lean more toward being against them. I think that they effect students and teachers negatively and portray the nations youth poorly.
As a student, I was always pushed by my parents to do my best. They did not give me choices on my future after high school; the only option I had was going to college. Growing up and not having much money to afford going to college, I felt the added pressure from my parents to do well in school. Part of doing well in school and being able to get scholarships and grants, was having to do well not only in classes, but on the standardized tests. The pressure was immense being only in my teens, causing me to become overly stressed and having constant mood swings with my family members. It also did not show how good of a student I was at the time. Like in my classes, I did well on everything I was taught, but was not the best when it came to taking tests because there was an added pressure. When I took the SATs, I scored low on the reading and writing portions, but I was an A student in my English classes. Looking back now, I do not think that my test scores really show how brilliant of a student I was.
As an educator in the same county I once went to school in, I can see another viewpoint when it comes to standardized tests. The feelings and struggles mentally that I endured while testing is also demonstrated by my students. I have students consistently missing class due to testing, which makes it difficult for them to keep up with the material after testing for 3 plus hours. It takes a told on their mental capacity. I had a student the other day come to me about their grade because they had to take almost every standardized test, so they could graduate, in turn missing almost a month’s worth of assignments. My student seemed very stressed and down because he was basically put into a whole with my class and others. By the time they had a moment to get caught up to some extent, there were only 2 days left in the quarter. I try to be understanding in that these tests are mandatory and that they serve a purpose that I just cannot wrap my head around, but what it is doing to students in the population I teach is unfair. Many students just sit for the test or do not take it at all because they have other means of getting the credit for it to graduate. There are projects students can take in place of standardized tests if they have failed them more than once, but students where I teach take advantage of that, making the days that they are getting pulled to test a waste of time that they could have been in class learning the material and not falling behind.
I know I may not understand the full meaning of standardized testing and what it may do for our nation, but I am 100% against it. I do feel that I may be very biased on this topic, but I have gone through the struggle and I see what my students go through as well. The amount of money that these tests costs are wasted on schools like the one I teach at because these students are not dumb and know they can get out of taking or passing a test by doing a project. The school system is allowing this to happen making it even more frustrating that a whole month and a half plus is dedicated to testing students back to back. I think that for students, there should be an alternative means of testing their abilities to pass certain subjects. In giving students some other form of summative assessment like the projects alone, I believe would help the demonstrate cumulative knowledge and mastery of a topic. Not all students excel in the same fields so by allowing them to do a creative project or something that they can use to show they know the subject should be enough in telling if a student is up to standards.

Successes

Being a teacher has been one of the biggest achievements in my life. I went from a career in finance and not knowing what I wanted to do w...